Free Website Traffic

Google Adsense Update shenanigans

We’ve been running all sorts of tests and experiments with our partner network’s blogs.  It’s only been one week into the current round of tweaking and testing and its already yielding some interesting nuggets of information.  Some findings:

1) Google adsense seems to go on a “freeze” mode if you update any element of the blog that impacts adsense code–themes, sidebars, ad code color, etc

2) Reducing the number of ads in an ad unit doesn’t necessarily boost CPC.  While CTR might increase (depending on your layout), the overall CPC can actually decline… by a lot.  This runs counter to the “conventional wisdom” that CPC rates will go up if you have less ad units since there’s less lower bidding ads appearing–those that appear would only be the winning high bids.  There is a possibility that the prevailing ‘wisdom’ might still be accurate even in the face of our own findings.  How?  The existence of some sort of Adsense “sandboxing” system for system changes.

3)  There’s a correlation between content quality and Adsense CPC.  Some may consider this a nobrainer since the right well-crafted text should be able to pull the right high value adsense ad.  It goes deeper than mere CPC keyword sniping though–the overall value of the content and its appeal to the viewer might be factored by Adsense regarding which ads to show.  We studied sites with high “stickiness” and multipage view or ‘deep browsing’ traffic patterns and compared their Adsense performance with high bounce rate shallow sites.  While not consistent across the board, we are convinced that the difference is substantial enough to warrant further investigation.   Content may be “king” when it comes to traffic…  It appears to also be very important when pulling juicy fat clicks from Adsense.

NOTE:  The partner network that has authorized us to do Adsense optimization and testing has over 100 blogs.  Not all the behaviors discussed above occurred in the same way or in the same rate.  This may be due to the fact that Adsense has differing data centers.  However, there’s enough of a common pattern that we can’t ignore these findings as quirks or one off events.  Anyone SERIOUS about boosting their adsense income would definitely find these patterns and experiments worth further investigation.

Feel free to share your own Adsense experiments’ results in the comments section.

Photo Credits: LUXAMART

Share on Facebook

Google index bans tied to Adsense?

google shotgunA trusted and highly esteemed colleague of mine who does real well with Adsense recently told me that all his sites running Adsense have been banned from Google.  He runs tons of other sites using differing sponsors and those sites have remained in Google’s index.

How do you know if your site is banned from google?  Do a search for site:YOURDOMAIN.com  If your site’s listings appear, you are not banned.

This banning seems very odd since he took great pains to use the following:

Differing class C ips
Differing Whois registrars
Differing niches
Differing designs/layouts
All original niche-specific content

In fact, all factors were different.  The only point of commonality is the Adsense Publisher ID.

Based on this information, it seems that the following is happening:

Google is “punishing” perceived “violations” of its policies by banning the offending sites through Adsense.  My colleague did nothing wrong–the sites weren’t scraped, he used only original content.  The links were completely white hat.  Note that he did not get banned from Adsense but from Google. Terrible implications for people building Made For Adsense (MFA) sites.

MFA sites get a bad rap because QUALITY made for adsense networks (like my colleague’s) are often lumped, unfairly, with cookie-cutter template-driven low content quality/scraped content sites.  Google’s been going after MFA sites with, it seems, indiscriminate shots from its BAN shotgun and it seems many legitimate publishers are caught in the blast range.

Leave a comment and let me know if you’ve suffered the same fate or know anyone who has.

Picture Credits

Share on Facebook

Testing Adsense Ad Placement Quantity

adsense dollarsThere are two schools of thought on Adsense ad placements’ effect on a site’s income.  The first focuses on quantity:  the more ads you have on your page, the higher the chance of a click through.  The other school focuses on quality: you stand to make more money with less clicks if you have less ads.  According to this latter idea, the advertisers’ Google Adwords ad auction operates to your favor since they have to compete even harder for placement on your page since there’s limited spots.  Moreover, the more ad spots on your page, the higher the chance someone will click those crappy <5 cent per click ad spots.

So which school of though is correct?  We suspect that it highly depends on your niche and traffic blend.  Regardless, we decided to test anyway.  We tested one of our more established sites and one of our incubated sites for eventual sale.  Here are the results so far.  We intend to monitor this periodically over the next week and focus on daily snapshots.

The first figure is the Click Through rate.  The second figure is the eCPM.  It is the best way to Adsense performance per page.  Here’s Google’s explanation of eCPM

Effective CPM

From a publisher’s perspective, the effective cost-per-thousand impressions (eCPM) is a useful way to compare revenue across different channels and advertising programs. It is calculated by dividing total earnings by the number of impressions in thousands. For example, if a publisher earned $180 from 45,000 impressions, the eCPM would equal $180/45, or $4.00. However, please keep in mind that eCPM is a reporting feature that does not represent the actual amount paid to a publisher.

SITE 1

CURRENT:  3.85%     $10.20

PREVIOUS MONTH: 6.90%     $7.74

SITE 2

CURRENT: 1.39%     $9.89

PREVIOUS MONTH: 2.66%     $5.75

The good news:  the eCPM is up by 31%  and 72%, respectively.
The bad news:  Click through rate is reduced sharply.  The CTR is down by 79% and   91%, respectively.

Preliminary Conclusion
So far, we’ve only been running this experiment for a couple of days or so, it appears that whatever has been gained by eCPM has been outweighed by CTR loss.   It’s still too early to conclude this experiment since the niches we’re covering with these two sites is known to carry sporadic high value clicks in rotation.  Bookmark this page and check back periodically to see our updates.

Photo Credits: Kevin Dooley

Share on Facebook